Author, Dr. Yetsa A Tuakli-Wosornu from the Sports Equity Lab has partnered with #WeRideTogether to collaborate and create this athlete-centered IOC Consensus Dissemination Project, which unpacks and elaborates on critical points from the IOC Consensus. The Dissemination Project will provide a 10-part series that highlights key takeaways from the IOC Consensus with visuals, activities, and social content that can be tangibly applied and integrated into sporting communities. This series aligns with the values and mission of both the Sports Equity Lab and #WeRideTogether to promote awareness on the topic of abuse in sports, eliminate inequities in sport, and provide everyone with accessible information on positive values and best practices to keep sports safe and healthy.
The 2024 IOC Safeguarding Consensus provides an overview of the various risk factors associated with experiences of interpersonal violence in sport. One of these risk factors is early sports specialization—the commitment to a single sport during development for over 8 months per year for prepubertal children.1 It is commonly seen in dance, gymnastics, swimming, figure skating, tennis, baseball, hockey, and soccer.
Due to love for the sport, the hot pursuit of potential, and pressure from adults, young athletes, parents, coaches, organizations, and society may not consider or be aware of the potential downsides that often accompany early sports specialization.
Early sports specialization has many risks to the young athlete, socially, psychologically, physically, and in terms of experiencing abuse and misconduct in their sport. Extra mindfulness and attention must be given to these concerns, as these developing athletes may not have the capacity to fully understand or consent to the risks that may potentially arise from specializing early in their sport.
Potential risks of early sports specialization:
Social
Psychological
Physical
Abuse and Misconduct19,20
“I started out OK, but at the end of the match I couldn’t wait to get off the court,” she told the newspaper. “Totally, mentally, I just lost it, and obviously, it goes deeper than that one match. I really was not happy with myself, my tennis, my life, my parents, my coaches, my friends. . . . When I looked in my mirror, I actually saw this distorted image: I was so ugly and fat, I just wanted to kill myself, really.” – Jennifer Capriati, Tennis
“I was overdriving myself because I was so into becoming the best,” Dell Done said. “I always thought someone else was working harder than me, which really made me go nuts with it. It wasn’t fun. It was like a job, and it was a job I wasn’t getting paid for.” – Elena Dell Done, Volleyball and Basketball
“No one ever asked me if I wanted to play tennis, let alone make it my life… I hate tennis, hate it with all my heart, and still I keep playing because I have no choice…I beg him [father] for a chance to play [soccer with friends]. He [father] shouts at the top of his lungs: ‘You’re a tennis player! You’re going to be number one in the world! You’re going to make lots of money. That’s the plan, and that’s the end of it.” – Andre Agassi, Tennis
“I had overuse injuries when I was swimming and ended up making them worse because I was pressured to keep going,” said Pawlichuk. “Or was scared that I was going to not get my spot on the national team or get cut from the relay. So, I just put the brave face on and kept going. Ended up being part of why I couldn’t swim through college.” – Dr. Danielle Pawlichuk, Swimming
"We listened to the scouts saying your child needs to play spring hockey," Susan said. "So we'd go from regular season straight into spring. You'd have maybe a couple weeks, then you do a camp. It starts very quick and you have no downtime." In 2016, the lack of downtime may have caught up to Connor, who felt his hip "pop" during a game. Doctors diagnosed him with a repetitive strain injury and pointed the finger at years of unvaried training. – Susan Cose, Mother of a young hockey player
According to medical science and evidence-based research, healthy alternatives, safeguards, and supports can be put in place for young athletes. Below lists recommendations, best practices, and facts and realities concerning early sports specialization and healthy childhood development.
Physical Safety26
Burnout27
Balanced Life28
Sports Success29
The bottom line is that when you say yes to one thing, you are essentially saying no to many other things. In terms of healthy child development, early sports specialization poses significant risks and a low chance of ‘reward’. Data show that only 1% of high school athletes receive any scholarships, between 3% and 11% compete at the college level, and only 0.3 and 05% reach professional sports; while as many as 70% discontinue playing organized sport by age 13, and at least 50% of athletic injuries are from overuse.31 From personal bodily harm to decreased social balance, educational costs, and vulnerabilities to experiencing abuse, a lot is at stake for young athletes who specialize early.
We must remember that young athletes are children, often placed in adult environments, facing demands that are typically meant for adults. These young athletes do not have fully developed brains or the capacity for far-sightedness, long-term thinking, and cost/benefit and cause/effect analysis. They are inherently influenced by societal expectations, their peers, coaches, and caregivers to determine what they want. Regardless, it is up to the adults in their lives to protect their holistic short-term and long-term best interests.
By all means, young athletes should pursue their passions and follow their hearts, fulfilling their potential. However, it is paramount that we educate and protect them in the process of their pursuits. Often, athletic organizations are driven by money and medals. Currently, they are inherently incentivized to keep the pipeline of young athletes coming, who typically have a short tenure in sports. Thus, athletes may be treated as disposable and replaceable, with a focus on results and outcomes rather than prioritizing the holistic well-being of each athlete. It is up to all of us to protect our athletes and protect our sports.
Here is what you can do to support young athletes who may have specialized early or are considering early sports specialization32,33,34:
Parents
Coaches
Organizations
Activity for Athletes
To reflect on the time and energy you spend in your sport and your corresponding feelings, use this activity tool. This activity can be repeated regularly to visually assess your sport life balance and how you are feeling about the different aspects of your life.
If you or someone you know needs support, please visit our Crisis Resources or Resources for assistance.
Kathryn McClain, MSW, MBA
Program and Partnerships Director at #WeRideTogether
kmcclain@weridetogether.today
Footnotes
References